The Hard Truth About Dying Without a Will in New York

what happens if i die without a will

So your time comes, and you haven’t sorted out your finances or end-of-life wishes. It happens – but when you die without any estate plan in New York, get ready for some serious unintended consequences. We’ve seen it play out painfully hundreds of times.

Without clearly outlined legal instructions guiding the distribution of your assets, New York law steps in with blankets of red tape and statutes determining estate recipients. A court-appointed administrator takes over handling your financial affairs and property distribution based solely on state intestacy rules — not your values or wishes.

From all-out family feuds to delays and mounting expenses, dying without a will often spells disaster for your estate. Avoid leaving your family to navigate preventable disputes. By legally documenting your wishes and working with an experienced estate planning attorney, you can ensure your assets go to loved ones and causes exactly as you intend.

No Last Will Means No Control Over Who Gets Your Money When You Die

In New York, dying without a will means your assets pass via the state’s intestacy laws – not according to your personal wishes.

The Surrogate’s Court will appoint an administrator to handle paying debts and taxes before divvying up the remainder among spouses, children, and other relatives in set proportions.

This administrator likely won’t be someone you’d choose to manage your estate. The distribution often shortchanges partners, close friends, or charities you care about without specific legally binding instructions.

For instance, take a married couple with no will and adult children from previous relationships. Upon passing, the surviving spouse would receive the first $50,000 and half the balance. Biological children split the rest, and stepchildren do not inherit unless adopted – rarely the outcome intended for blended families. An experienced estate planning attorney will help make sure children get inheritance the way that you intend.

New York Intestacy Laws and Estate Distribution

Under New York’s intestacy laws, the spouse, children, and other relatives receive predetermined shares that frequently fuel disputes.

New York has clear guidelines that determine who inherits the assets of someone who dies without a will, known as dying intestate. The distribution rules aim to provide for the closest family members and dependents of the deceased (called the Decedent).

Under New York’s intestacy laws, the spouse, children, and other relatives receive predetermined shares that frequently fuel disputes.

Here’s an overview of how intestate estates are distributed:

  • If the Decedent has a spouse but no children, the spouse inherits everything. This applies whether the spouse is a husband or wife.
  • If there are children but no spouse: The Decedent’s children will split the estate equally among themselves. If any children predeceased the Decedent but left descendants (the Decedent’s grandchildren), the grandchildren can stand in the place of their parent and inherit their share.
  • If the Decedent has a spouse AND children: The spouse inherits the first $50,000 plus 50% of the remainder of the estate. Any children of the Decedent split the other 50% of the balance equally. If any of the children died before the Decedent but left descendants, the grandchildren inherit their parent’s share.
  • If there is no spouse or children/grandchildren: The estate is distributed first to the Decedent’s parents in equal shares. If the parents are deceased, then any siblings (brothers/sisters) of the Decedent inherit the estate in equal shares.
  • If NONE of the above categories of family members exist and the Decedent has no family at all – the estate goes to the State of New York.

Heirs can legally contest the estate administration if dissatisfied with the assets they receive. Over the years, The Browne Firm has mediated relatives quarreling over possessions from antique jewelry to entire homes. Without legal documentation of your wishes, assumptions clash, and opinions differ dramatically on who should inherit what.

The Estate Administration Process in New York

In the absence of a will, New York’s estate administration process takes over to assess and distribute your estate. A close family member, like a surviving spouse, children, or parents, must file for administration.

Once begun, this court-supervised inventory, appraisal, and distribution procedure often takes over a year, with assets tied up while debts clear.

The delays not only frustrate inheritors but prevent them from accessing funds during an already turbulent transition. Attorney and filing fees also steadily diminish estate value. And the court-appointed administrator receives sizable fees for their time spent facilitating the process.

What No One Tells You About Dying Without an Estate Plan

Dying without an estate plan causes severe unintended consequences you likely didn’t realize. Here are 5 main issues that can result:

#1 Assets Don’t Go to Your Intended Beneficiaries

Without legal guidance dictating asset distribution, special friends, partners, and charities you care deeply about will receive no inheritance. Only blood relatives and surviving legal spouses are eligible under state intestacy laws. So, philanthropies you avidly donated to can lose key support, and close companions can unjustly get cut out.

#2 Family Infighting Over the Estate

With no definitive record of your exact distribution intentions, relatives end up disputing the estate and quarreling bitterly over possessions in front of probate judges. Even amicable families face scrutiny without written plans on dividing heirlooms, property, and financial assets fairly based on merit or need.

#3 Lengthy Delays Accessing Inheritance

New York’s court-supervised estate administration commonly spans well over 12 months – even in straightforward cases without family disputes. Until the administrator fully inventories assets, discharges all debts, and receives court permission, no inheritor can access funds. These painful lags leave loved ones empty-handed exactly when they could benefit most from inheritance support.

#4 Unnecessary Fees Steadily Drain Assets

Between administrator compensation, surrogate court filing expenses, and added legal costs, estate funds face serious erosion. The intestate fees alone often reach 5% of the estate’s entire gross value. So unintended administrative costs siphon away assets that could have instead directly supported family or charities per your values.

#5 You Lose Out on Tax Savings

Without savvy advance planning, those dying intestate lose out on numerous legal maneuvers allowing estate tax reductions. Strategies like trusts, gifting, and asset repositioning could have sheltered millions extra in New York. Yet without meticulous arrangements explicitly outlining specialized tax guidance, huge savings evaporate.

How a Simple Will or Trust Can Save Your Legacy

Crafting a plan allows you to distribute assets as YOU truly intend, no questions asked. It also handles key facets beyond asset division, like naming an executor, appointing guardians for minor children, and establishing inheritance trusts.

Bottom line — if you pass without documenting your wishes, you invite preventable disputes, delays and expenses. Protect your legacy by proactively creating a customized will or trust document that addresses asset distribution, executor appointments, guardianship considerations, and more.

As experienced probate attorneys dealing with hundreds of complex estate cases over our years of practice, our team simplifies things. Get in touch to safeguard your estate.

Contact us today to begin preparing your legacy.


Author Bio

Danielle Browne is the founder and managing attorney of The Browne Firm, a New York-based estate planning and business law firm. Danielle leverages her background, serving as general counsel for a Fortune 500 company and working with startups to represent clients in entity formation, intellectual property protection, contract drafting, estate planning, and more.

With more than ten years of experience as an attorney and business executive, she has represented clients ranging from entrepreneurs and small businesses to artists and Fortune 500 companies. Danielle received her Juris Doctor cum laude from the University of Miami School of Law and is licensed to practice in New York. She has received numerous honors for her work, including being named a 2015 Future Leader by the WNBA President while serving as general counsel for the Atlanta Dream.

LinkedIn | State Bar Association | Avvo | Google